Log in

No account? Create an account
27 August 2008 @ 11:09 am
2 Things that Make No Sense and 1 Thing that Does  
1) [very mild casting spoiler for future DW] Alienating a large part of your fanbase is not very intelligent.

I'm not particularly offended by the comment myself (mostly because I think he's completely wrong, there's too much evidence to the contrary), but there seem to be a lot of Rose and Rose/Doctor fans who are. It doesn't make sense to me for a writer to just be on the cusp of taking over a very successful show to belittle one of the characters who probably helped said show reach its popularity; and by association then offend said characters fans. Just sayin'.

2) This is why I think musicians (and other famous people, really) should not make political statements.

I know that it's Madonna and really, who takes her very seriously; but still. Why, oh why, would a person ever conceive of making a comparison like that? Hitler and Robert Mugabe are not camparable to John McCain. They just aren't. McCain will not be slaughtering hundreds of people due to their religious beliefs or race or for any other reason were he to become president, mmmkay? And as far as I can tell, this presidential race is still democratic and I think that Americans have their form of democracy too ingrained in them to relinquish it, so there should be no fear of dictatorship. My eyes pretty much rolled out of my sockets upon reading that. I almost can't believe anyone could be so fucking stupid. I do wonder at the response of the crowd though, if the Welsh people cheered I really want to know why.

1) Fandom Free-For-All, fandoms coming together XD!

pheebs1 and oxoniensis are hosting a Fall Fandom Free-For-All which looks like it could be a lot of fun. Details here, the bare gist of it is that you comment with up to 10 things you'd like (fic, graphics, fanvid, whatever) and then you read through other people's lists and find something to do for them. In the end, everyone should come away with something they really have always wanted. They ask that if you post a list of your own, that you find someone for whom you can make something too. A fair trade! =D!
Current Location: home
Current Mood: coldcold
Pheebs1pheebs1 on August 27th, 2008 06:50 pm (UTC)
Thanks for the pimp!
kePPy: SPN: Boys b&w memory lanekepp0xy on August 31st, 2008 03:24 am (UTC)
thanks for the free for all! ;D!
level five laser lotus: dw rose & tentvheartache on August 28th, 2008 03:55 am (UTC)
Definitely agree with you on the Rose thing. I loved the episodes he's written, but wow, way to piss off a good chunk of fandom. Hah, I think it was kind of unprofessional of him too - Rose was RTD's baby, just like River Song (um, that was her last name, right?) is Moffat's. And I gotta say, Rose >>>> River.

And holy crap, that Madonna article does not make her look intelligent in any way.
kePPy: Dr Who: Rose pwns you. hardcore.kepp0xy on August 31st, 2008 03:29 am (UTC)
Yeah... I don't think it's smart at all. And the thing is, CLEARLY, she isn't needy. He was the one moping for an entire season about losing her; the angst being so strong as to filter into his human!dreams. Hell, even Donna shipped them and he can't deny that. Rose, on the other hand, fought her way back. I don't think that's needy, I think that's determination & dedication. Needy would be sitting on her ass waiting for him to come save her, or clinging to the next guy. And River Song was a nice idea, but either 1) not well written in practice or 2) Alex Kingston was not right for the role. I think both are true, but that 2 is a bit more the reason than 1. I just didn't believe her.

And also, he hasn't even taken over the series yet. How arrogant to insult such a popular character before proving himself a good show runner to fandom, ya know? *not impressed*

tch. Madonna = painfully idiotic. I never thought she was Einstein, but i didn't think she was that dumb.

omg, yet another long comment *_*